Review: Mr. Morale or Mr. Mediocre?
Kendrick Lamar’s fifth album monotone, mediocre
May 31, 2022
It’s been five years since Kendrick Lamar released his last album “DAMN,” and with such a big gap, the response to “Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers” was astounding — with Spotify and Apple Music crashing the day after its release from fans flocking to listen to Lamar’s newest creation. However, once you actually listen to Lamar’s fifth album, it’s clear that he played it safe.
“Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers” is a double album featuring 18 songs split between two nine-track sections. It features many collaborations, and sticks to a mainly hip-hop theme, but also explores elements of jazz and funk. The album has many highs, but it has just as many lows — making for a largely average album.
There are a few notable songs on the album, one being “Mother I Sober,” A sharp contrast from the rest of the tracks on the album, “Mother I Sober” takes on a largely soft and spoken tone. The beat is largely the same, and it’s paired with beautiful piano. Usually a beat like this would create a monotone feel, but the piano accompaniment is so organic that it morphs the beat into something new. The simplicity of the backing music really allows the songs theme to shine: being anti-substance abuse, an addiction to sexual intimacy and coping with questions about assault as a child. Overall, “Mother I Sober” is a harrowing song that stands apart from the rest of Lamar’s album for its delicate addressing of hard topics.
Another notable song is “United In Grief,” The first song on “Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers” this song sets a unique tone for the album. Starting off with organic vocals, mixed with pure talking, “United In Grief” sets up this album to shine. One of a few featured artists on this album, Sam Dew, begins the song singing through Lamar’s inner lens. This is a common theme on the album, and “United In Grief” does a good job at setting this up. Lamar covers several topics within “United In Grief”, a notable one being his unfaithfulness in his marriage with Whitney Alford. With a variety of pace, tone and sound, “United In Grief” is never boring. Lamar utilizes modern beats, orchestration and rhythm to create a compelling sound. However, this cannot be said for all of Lamar’s songs.
While there are some high points within the album, Lamar creates just as many lows. For the majority of “Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers,” the beginning of the songs are promising. They start with organic beats, unique vocals and distinctive rhythm. However, as the songs progress they tend to morph into generic sound. By the end of the songs, it’s hard to tell them apart since they’ve all transformed into a generic “Kendrick” sound.
But the lowest-low of “Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers” has to be the song “Auntie Diaries.” The song has a strong theme: a child learning to accept a trans relative. This song had the potential to be amazing, to change hip hop and begin a trend of inclusivity and address a controversial topic … until Lamar used a slur 10 times. “Auntie Diaries” is supposed to be an ode to trans acceptance, with a goal to convince people to stop saying anti-LGBTQ+ slurs. However, to achieve this Lamar decided to use said anti-LGTBQ+ slurs. The slur Lamar used in “Auntie Diaries” has a deep history that’s intertwined with LGTBQ+ violence and hate. While Lamar attempted to make a great point, it ultimately fell flat and came off as offensive and out of touch.
Overall, “Mr. Morale & the Big Steppers” high moments are easily forgettable with the amount of mediocre filler music in between. Is this a bad album? No. But it’s certainly not one to rave about either. This album is a good choice for a summer playlist or background music, but don’t expect to be completely encapsulated in the sound.
Bender • Jun 2, 2022 at 2:27 pm
Why are people like you payed for not doig the basics of their job?
Reviewers are relistening to album for weeks if it falls flat to them but they sense it might become better.
It is as claer as it can be that this review is based on some subjective conclusions that are shallow and are not protected with arguments.
Impressive fail
Guy • Jun 2, 2022 at 8:52 am
This is one of the worst reviews I’ve ever read, completely missed the point of the album, the album is amazing and so many of its layers went right over your thick skull apparently
Christina • Jun 2, 2022 at 1:38 am
Anya Panday, your review is reductive and myopic!
This review recycles talking points rooted in shaming vulnerability. How much time did you spend listening to each song before you wrote this? What methodology did you use? And if none then what credentials, with regards to rap and hip-hop, do you have for your opinion to matter?
Your writing ‘this song had the potential to be amazing, to change hip hop and begin a trend of inclusivity and address a controversial topic … until Lamar used a slur 10 times’ implies that Kendrick Lamar’s objective is be the saviour of rap. But did you not understand ‘Saviour’? Don’t you think your comment contradicts the message of that song? Throughout Lamar’s career ( I think) he has been quite consistent in expressing his lack of interest in being your ‘woke’ messiah.
Remember ‘Ignorance Is Bliss?’ Ever heard it? If so, why continue to box him into that position if that’s not how he sees himself?
Are you only reviewing ‘Mr. Morale and the Big Steppers’ because you want to trend Anya Panday?
Huuunh • Jun 1, 2022 at 10:36 pm
Pathetic and easy surface level review.
Quintin • Jun 1, 2022 at 1:23 pm
The writer only listened to Auntie Diaries and decided to review. Your review is more political and view based rather than hip hop music based.
Mr. Chapman • Jun 1, 2022 at 12:30 pm
I knew that this would be a sham review as soon as you made the claim that he “played it safe”. There’s nothing safe about this album. I don’t think we’ve ever seen this level of vulnerability from a hip hop artist. The only question I’m left with after listening to this album several times and reading your review, is what actually qualifies you pass judgment.
XIII • Jun 1, 2022 at 10:11 am
I see why Kendrick didn’t drop any music his whole album is basically a therapy session but nowadays people don’t wanna listen, that’s what’s wrong with the media they want to hear what they want to hear rather than what needs to be heard and regardless of the f slurs Kendrick said in a song that’s about him coming to his senses and realizing that he was wrong but the media doesn’t like to listen its sad how these”fans”all across the media and the world they want these albums from these rappers but whenever a rapper decides to make speak some truth or make something about their personal life or speak on something thats going on in the world they don’t listen they switch up they like insturmetals the basses and hard lyrics but when a mf says something truthful its either not acknowledge or everyone in their feels I see why Kendrick hasn’t released anything till now the world isn’t ready for what needs to be said or heard from his mouth and its been proven its sad
kendrick the 🐐 • Jun 2, 2022 at 9:03 pm
use punctuation challenge
Bob • Jun 1, 2022 at 8:00 am
No mention of Father Time or several other great songs. Also I have no idea how this album “plays it safe” when Kendrick so clearly didn’t care about the sales of the album. Only one song is actually very popular (n95) and the rest are just Kendrick doing what he wants. Because he so clearly doesn’t care about the sales it makes this album deeply personal on a level he’s never reached before which makes up for the somewhat inconsistent production in my opinion.
Emir Salamazar • Jun 1, 2022 at 5:31 am
Mr morales and the big mediocre used slur!! Bad I’d say mid/10 this review sux!!!
kendrick the 🐐 • Jun 2, 2022 at 9:02 pm
W comment
Honest • May 31, 2022 at 5:37 pm
Anya Panday u gave a horrible review u didn’t even mention the song crown where he’s talking directly to critics like u that he can’t please… plus im not LGBTQ but appreciate the storytelling on auntie dairies that is what hip-hop is about… there is great storytelling on this album a break away from drake’s repeated same style commercial album he puts out every year and J Coles sleepy last few albums… someone has to take risks that what makes hip-hop move forward… I love drake but im sooo tired of him that i completely ignored Jack Harlow album which is the diet version SMH
ALLOW RAPPERS TO BE DIFFERENT
Bro • Jun 3, 2022 at 1:30 am
Thank God reviews like yours are just that, opinions that become irrelevant and actually funny to read in years to come… MM&TBS is a masterpiece and that’s a fact!
Scott • May 31, 2022 at 4:05 pm
The ‘slurs’ you refer to are representative of his ignorance at the time. Its quite clear when you actually listen to the track.
I’m always weary of reviews coming out so close to the release, real hiphop with layers to it are maybe not for everyone.