The rivalry between Benilde-St. Margaret’s and Park will continue because of a Nov. 1 denial of the appeal to remove Benilde from the Metro-West conference.

According to Superintendent Rob Metz, the hearing officer chose to place Benilde in the conference because of its similarity in size to other schools.

“Even though Benilde is similar to us in size, in terms of sports they should be competing against bigger schools,” Metz said.

Metz said he does not think Benilde’s approach to sports fits with those of other schools in the conference.

“We believe sports are important, and we should focus on development—not necessarily going to State in many things—although we might occasionally,” Metz said. “Benilde has a different philosophy. For them it’s about winning as much as you can.”

However, freshman Marcie James said she is glad the Orioles will continue to compete against the Red Knights.

“I think it’s good to have Benilde in our conference, because it’s healthy competition and they’re at our ability level,” James said.

Regardless of skill level, athletic director Andy Ewald said he expected the decision.

“I’m not surprised, but disappointed,” Ewald said. “There has never been an appeal granted before.”

Now that the appeal has gone before an independent hearing, the athletic office has no way to further appeal Benilde’s placement.

Ewald said although he dislikes Benilde’s placement, he plans to focus on Park.

“It’s disappointing but at some point you have to move on and control what you can: ourselves and our programs,” he said.